Both are cozy games where you deliver mail to animal neighbors, but one is a tiny forest platformer and the other is a sailing game. Mail Time (Kela van der Deijl, 2023) is a 2-hour platformer about a little mail scout in a forest. In A Short Sail, a tabby cat carries letters and parcels between islands by sailboat. Pick Mail Time for one sweet afternoon, and A Short Sail for a longer life at sea.
Short answer first: if you want a tiny, sweet game to finish this afternoon, play Mail Time. If you loved its job and want to do it by boat, with more to come back to, try A Short Sail. We make A Short Sail, and Mail Time is a game we are fond of, so we tried hard to be fair.
Who makes each game
Mail Time is by Kela van der Deijl, a solo developer. It came out in 2023 and is on PC, Mac, Switch, PS4 and PS5. It takes about 2 hours, according to HowLongToBeat, and it is rated Playable on Steam Deck.
A Short Sail is also made by a solo developer, Yos Riady. It is still in development and coming to Steam and itch.io in Q1 2027, for PC (Windows), Mac, the web and Steam Deck. The free demo plays in your browser now at play.ashortsail.com.
What is alike
The post is the whole point. In Mail Time you are a new mail scout, and each letter you deliver leads to the next. In A Short Sail, you pick up letters and parcels, pack them into your hold and deliver them to folks.
Animal neighbors. Mail Time’s forest is full of small animals with small worries. In A Short Sail, the islanders are animals too, and they become your friends when you help them.
Delivery as a way to meet people. In both games a letter is a reason to knock on a door. You learn who everyone is by bringing them their post.
Gentle from start to end. Neither game has enemies on land, and neither has a clock.
Made by one person. Both come from a solo developer, and both are small on purpose.
What is different
How you get around. Mail Time is a 3D platformer. You run, jump and glide on a paper glider between mushrooms and tree roots. A Short Sail is a sailing game. You catch the wind in your sail and steer your sailboat from island to island, then walk ashore.
The size of the world. In Mail Time you are the size of a mushroom, and the world is one corner of a forest. In A Short Sail the world is a sea of little islands, with tall sea stacks and old ruins standing in the water.
How much there is to do. Mail Time is about the letters, plus some things to collect. A Short Sail adds a lot round the post: you fish by day and by night, dig up treasure with the maps you find, play music, snorkel over reefs, join weekly events and build your home island.
A home. In A Short Sail you build your home island, one plank at a time, and give it a name of your own. Mail Time has no home to keep.
Length. Mail Time is about 2 hours, and it is finished when the letters are delivered. A Short Sail is a bigger game with days to come back to. Its length is not set yet.
Sea battles. Mail Time has no combat at all. A Short Sail has gentle sea battles against storms and living waves, with no timers.
Alone or together. Mail Time is single-player. A Short Sail plays alone or online with friends.
Out now or coming soon. Mail Time is out now. A Short Sail comes in Q1 2027, and only its demo is out now.
Side by side
| Mail Time | A Short Sail | |
|---|---|---|
| Developer | Kela van der Deijl | Yos Riady |
| Release | 2023 | Q1 2027 (in development) |
| You play | A tiny mail scout | A tabby cat with a sailboat |
| Kind of game | 3D platformer | Sailing game |
| Where | A forest | A sea of little islands |
| Main thing you do | Deliver letters on foot and by glider | Deliver mail by sailboat, fish and make friends |
| Combat | None | Gentle sea battles only, no timers |
| Multiplayer | Single-player | Alone or online with friends |
| Length | About 2 hours (HowLongToBeat) | Not shared yet |
Bottom line: Mail Time is the better pick for one short, sweet sitting. A Short Sail is the better pick if you want the same delivery job by boat, with fishing, friends, a home to build and online play.
Who should play which
Play Mail Time if you want something small and kind that you can finish tonight. It is one of the sweetest delivery games there is. For more like it, see our games like Mail Time.
Play A Short Sail if you finished Mail Time and wished the round went on, with a boat, a fishing line and a home of your own. Try the free demo first: it runs in your browser, and your save carries over to the full game.
Play both if you like the idea of the post as a way to make friends. Our cozy mail delivery games and cozy delivery games lists have more.
Our own game
We make A Short Sail, so this page is not neutral. Mail Time is out now and well loved, and you can get it on Steam.
Questions
Is A Short Sail like Mail Time?
In its job, yes: A Short Sail is like Mail Time because in both you bring letters to animal characters and get to know them. Mail Time is a short 3D platformer in a forest. A Short Sail is a sailing game between islands, with fishing, friends and a home to build as well.
Which is better for a quick play?
Mail Time is better for a quick play. It takes about 2 hours and is complete in one sitting. A Short Sail is a bigger game. Its length is not set yet, but you can try its free demo in your browser.
Does either game have combat?
Mail Time has none. A Short Sail has no fighting on foot. At sea it has gentle battles against storms and living waves, never people or animals, and there are no timers.
Is there jumping and platforming in A Short Sail?
It is not a platformer. You sail, walk the islands and chat with the islanders, and you can get a snorkel to swim over reefs. Mail Time is the one built around jumping and gliding.
Can I play either with friends?
Mail Time is single-player. A Short Sail plays alone or online with friends: host a lobby or join one by its code or from a list of public lobbies, chat, ride along in a friend's boat and play flag tag.
Which platforms are they on?
Mail Time is on PC, Mac, Switch, PS4 and PS5. A Short Sail comes to Steam and itch.io in Q1 2027 for PC (Windows), Mac, the web and Steam Deck. It has no console plans.
