A Short Sail vs Little Kitty, Big City: which to play?

A Short Sail and Little Kitty, Big City both let you play as a cat in a kind world. An honest comparison of what is alike and what is different.

By Yos Riady · Published · Last checked:

Both let you play as a cat in a kind world, but one is a city to cause trouble in and the other is a sea to work on. Little Kitty, Big City (Double Dagger Studio, 2024) is a short game about a lost kitten finding its way home. In A Short Sail, a tabby cat with a sailboat delivers mail, fishes and makes friends. Pick Little Kitty for mischief, and A Short Sail for a job and a boat.

Short answer first: if you want to be a real cat for an afternoon, play Little Kitty, Big City. If you want to be a cat with a sailboat and a round to make, try A Short Sail. We make A Short Sail, and we love Little Kitty, so we tried hard to be fair.

Who makes each game

Little Kitty, Big City is by Double Dagger Studio. It came out in 2024 and is on PC, Switch, PlayStation and Xbox. It is Verified for Steam Deck and takes about 2.5 hours for the main story, according to HowLongToBeat.

A Short Sail is made by Yos Riady, a solo developer. It is still in development and coming to Steam and itch.io in Q1 2027, for PC (Windows), Mac, the web and Steam Deck. The free demo plays in your browser now at play.ashortsail.com.

What is alike

You are a cat. Little Kitty is a small black kitten. In A Short Sail you are a little tabby cat.

Other animals need a hand. Little Kitty meets a crow, a tanuki, a dog and more, and each has a favor to ask. In A Short Sail, you help the islanders with their requests, and they become your friends, shown as hearts.

A small open world. Both give you a place to wander in any order, with corners to poke into. Neither is huge, and both are better for it.

Nothing to fear on foot. Neither game has enemies on land, and neither has a clock. You go at your own pace.

Photos. Both let you stop and take pictures of the places you find.

What is different

City or sea. Little Kitty, Big City is set in a few sunny streets of a Japanese city: gardens, rooftops, a shopping lane. A Short Sail is set on a sea of little islands, with beaches, sea stacks and old ruins standing in the water.

Being a cat or having a job. Little Kitty is about cat things. You climb, pounce on birds, trip people up, steal a phone and knock plant pots off walls. It is mischief with no cost. A Short Sail is a working life: you pick up letters and parcels, pack them into your hold and deliver them to folks.

Getting around. Little Kitty walks, jumps and climbs. In A Short Sail, you catch the wind in your sail and steer your sailboat from island to island, then walk ashore.

A real cat or a storybook cat. Little Kitty moves on four legs and meows. The cat in A Short Sail stands upright and chats with the neighbors, more like a character in a picture book.

How much there is to do. Little Kitty is short and focused on getting home. A Short Sail has more round its edges: you fish by day and by night, dig up treasure with the maps you find, play music, snorkel over reefs, join weekly events and build your home island.

Sea battles. Little Kitty has no combat at all. A Short Sail has gentle sea battles against storms and living waves, with no timers.

Alone or together. Little Kitty, Big City is single-player. A Short Sail plays alone or online with friends.

Out now or coming soon. Little Kitty, Big City is out now. A Short Sail comes in Q1 2027, and only its demo is out now.

Side by side

Little Kitty, Big City A Short Sail
Developer Double Dagger Studio Yos Riady
Release 2024 Q1 2027 (in development)
You play A lost black kitten A tabby cat with a sailboat
Where A sunny city A sea of little islands
Main thing you do Explore, cause mischief and get home Deliver mail, fish and make friends
Moving around Walk, jump and climb Sail, walk and snorkel
Combat None Gentle sea battles only, no timers
Multiplayer Single-player Alone or online with friends
Length About 2.5 hours main story (HowLongToBeat) Not shared yet

Bottom line: Little Kitty, Big City is the better pick if you want to be a real cat for one afternoon. A Short Sail is the better pick if you want a cat with a job, a sailboat and friends to come back to.

Who should play which

Play Little Kitty, Big City if you want to be a cat, plainly and joyfully, for one afternoon. It is funny and warm, and it does not outstay its welcome. For more like it, see our games like Little Kitty, Big City.

Play A Short Sail if you liked helping the neighborhood animals most of all, and want a longer game built round that, with a boat of your own. Try the free demo first: it runs in your browser, and your save carries over to the full game.

Play both if you like cats. Our cozy cat games list has more, and so does cozy games where you play as an animal.

Our own game

We make A Short Sail, so this page is not neutral. Little Kitty, Big City is out now, and you can get it on Steam.

Questions

Is A Short Sail like Little Kitty, Big City?

A little: A Short Sail is like Little Kitty, Big City in that you are a cat who helps other animals in a gentle world. Little Kitty, Big City is about being a real cat in a city: climbing, napping, knocking things over. A Short Sail is about sailing between islands with the post.

Which cat acts more like a real cat?

The kitten in Little Kitty, Big City acts more like a real cat. It walks on four legs, squeezes through gaps, chases birds and knocks pots off ledges. The cat in A Short Sail is a storybook cat who walks upright, talks to the neighbors and sails a boat.

Which game is longer?

Little Kitty, Big City takes about 2.5 hours for the main story, according to HowLongToBeat. A Short Sail is a bigger game with days to come back to. Its length is not set yet.

Does either game have combat?

Little Kitty, Big City has none. A Short Sail has no fighting on foot. At sea it has gentle battles against storms and living waves, never people or animals, and there are no timers.

Can you dress up the cat?

In Little Kitty, Big City you collect dozens of hats. In A Short Sail, most of your customizing goes into your boat, with new sails, hulls and more, and in online play you pick your own animal.

Are both on Steam Deck?

Little Kitty, Big City is Verified for Steam Deck. A Short Sail comes to Steam in Q1 2027 for PC (Windows), Mac, the web and Steam Deck, and its free demo plays in your browser now.

A Short Sail

The cozy sailing game with a cat.

Coming soon to Steam and itch.ioPlay the free demo