Is A Short Sail like Zelda: The Wind Waker?

A Short Sail and The Wind Waker share a small sailboat, a bright sea of islands and treasure maps. An honest look at what is alike and what is different.

By Yos Riady · Published · Last checked:

In its sea, yes. In its play, no. Both games give you a small sailboat, a bright cartoon ocean, little islands and treasure maps. The Wind Waker is a Zelda adventure with dungeons and a sword. A Short Sail is a cozy game: a tabby cat delivers mail, fishes and makes friends, with no fighting on foot.

Short answer first: if you loved sailing between islands in The Wind Waker and want that feeling as a calm game of its own, A Short Sail is for you. If you loved the dungeons and the sword, it is not. We make A Short Sail, and The Wind Waker is one of the reasons we wanted to. Here is the honest comparison.

Who makes each game

The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker is made by Nintendo. It came out for the GameCube in Japan in 2002 and in the rest of the world in 2003, and an HD version followed on Wii U in 2013. It has never had a PC release.

A Short Sail is made by Yos Riady, a solo developer. It is still in development and coming to Steam and itch.io in Q1 2027, for PC (Windows), Mac, the web and Steam Deck. The free demo plays in your browser now at play.ashortsail.com.

What is alike

A small boat on a wide, bright sea. In The Wind Waker, Link crosses the Great Sea in a little red boat with a single sail. In A Short Sail, you catch the wind in your sail and steer your sailboat from island to island. In both, the sea is the world, and most of your time is spent on it.

Little islands, each with something to find. The Great Sea is a chart of small islands, and part of the joy is filling it in. A Short Sail has little islands with their own beaches and secrets, and tall sea stacks, rock arches and old ruins standing in the water between them.

Treasure maps. Link finds treasure charts and hauls chests up from the sea floor. In A Short Sail, you dig up treasure with the maps you find.

A cartoon look that stays fresh. The Wind Waker is the best-known cel-shaded game there is. A Short Sail has bright low-poly islands in flat colors, with cel-shaded animal characters. Neither tries to look real.

The post. This one is a small delight. The Wind Waker has a postal service run by the bird-like Rito, with a mail-sorting job on one island. In A Short Sail, the post is your whole job, and Pip, a pelican, runs the island’s post office.

Day, night and weather. Both seas turn from day to night, and both have rain and storms.

Photos and music. Link carries a camera called the Picto Box and conducts tunes with the Wind Waker. In A Short Sail there is a photo mode, and you find instruments and tunes and play music, and islanders may join in as a little band.

What is different

An adventure or a routine. The Wind Waker is an adventure with a beginning and an end: your sister is taken, and you set out to save her. A Short Sail is a cozy routine. The islands need your help, you deliver the post, and you build friendships over many days. It has secrets to uncover, at your own pace. We will not spoil them.

Combat. The Wind Waker has sword fights, bosses and dungeons full of enemies. A Short Sail has no fighting on foot, only gentle sea battles against storms and living waves, and there are no timers.

Dungeons and puzzles. Much of The Wind Waker happens inside dungeons, with keys, switches and new tools. A Short Sail has none of that. You get a snorkel and swim over reefs and old ruins under the sea, but they are places to look at, not to fight through.

A job and a home. In A Short Sail, you pick up letters and parcels, pack them into your hold and deliver them to folks. You fish by day and by night. You build your home island, one plank at a time, and give it a name of your own. Link has no home to keep and no round to make.

Friends. The islanders in A Short Sail become your friends when you help them, shown as hearts. The Wind Waker has a lovely cast, but you pass through their lives on the way to somewhere else.

The wind. Link changes the wind’s direction with a magic baton. In A Short Sail the wind is simply there to catch.

Alone or together. The Wind Waker is for one player. A Short Sail plays alone or online with friends: host a lobby or join one by its code or from a list of public lobbies, chat, ride along in a friend’s boat and play flag tag.

Size. The Wind Waker is a big game from a big studio. A Short Sail is a smaller game from one developer. Its length is not set yet.

Side by side

The Wind Waker A Short Sail
Developer Nintendo Yos Riady
Release 2002 (HD in 2013) Q1 2027 (in development)
You play Link, a boy from a small island A tabby cat with a sailboat
Main thing you do Explore, fight and clear dungeons Deliver mail between islands, fish and make friends
The boat A small sailboat that talks A small sailboat you customize
Combat Sword fights, bosses, sea battles Gentle sea battles only, no timers
Treasure Charts and sunken chests Maps and treasure to dig up
Home None Your home island, with a name of your own
Multiplayer Single-player Alone or online with friends
Platforms GameCube, Wii U PC (Windows), Mac, Web, Steam Deck

Bottom line: The Wind Waker is the pick for a grand adventure with dungeons and a sword. A Short Sail is the pick if the sailing was your favorite part and you want it as a calm game on a computer.

Who should play which

Play The Wind Waker if you want a grand adventure and have the console for it. It is one of the best games ever made, and its sea has never been bettered. If you want something like it on a computer, see our games like Wind Waker on PC.

Play A Short Sail if your favorite part of The Wind Waker was the sailing itself: the wind, the horizon, a small island coming into view. It keeps that and adds a gentle life around it, with the post, a fishing line and animal friends. Try the free demo first: it runs in your browser, and your save carries over to the full game.

Play both if you can. One is a journey, and the other is a place to come back to. Our best cozy sailing games and best cel-shaded games on PC have more.

Our own game

We make A Short Sail, so this page is not neutral. We tried to be fair. The Wind Waker is a far bigger game and a classic, and we would not compare the two as equals. We compare them because players ask.

Questions

Is A Short Sail a Zelda game?

No, it is not a Zelda game. The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker is made by Nintendo. Our game is a separate one, made by Yos Riady, a solo developer. They share a bright sea and a small sailboat, but no characters, story or world.

Can I play The Wind Waker on PC?

Not officially. The Wind Waker has only come out on Nintendo consoles. A Short Sail comes to Steam and itch.io in Q1 2027 for PC (Windows), Mac, the web and Steam Deck, and its free demo plays in your browser now.

Does A Short Sail have dungeons or sword fights?

No. A Short Sail has no dungeons and no fighting on foot. At sea there are gentle battles against storms and living waves, never people or animals, and there are no timers. The rest of the time you deliver mail, fish, chat and build your home island.

Does A Short Sail have wind like The Wind Waker?

Yes. In A Short Sail you catch the wind in your sail and steer from island to island. You do not change the wind with a magic baton, as Link does. Sailing is how you get around and how you do your job.

Are there treasure maps in A Short Sail?

Yes. In A Short Sail you dig up treasure with the maps you find. In The Wind Waker you pull treasure up from the sea floor with a grappling hook. Both give you a reason to sail to a quiet spot on the chart.

Is A Short Sail cel shaded like The Wind Waker?

Partly. In A Short Sail, the animal characters are cel shaded, with light in soft bands. The islands and the sea are low-poly, in flat colors. The Wind Waker is cel shaded throughout.

A Short Sail

The cozy sailing game with a cat.

Coming soon to Steam and itch.ioPlay the free demo