---
title: "A Short Sail vs Spiritfarer: which to play? | A Short Sail"
description: "A Short Sail and Spiritfarer are both cozy boat games about caring for animal friends. An honest comparison of what is alike and what differs."
url: https://ashortsail.com/blog/a-short-sail-vs-spiritfarer/
published: 2026-12-30
updated: 2026-12-30
author: "Yos Riady"
image: https://ashortsail.com/og/blog/a-short-sail-vs-spiritfarer.jpg
---

# A Short Sail vs Spiritfarer: which to play?

A Short Sail and Spiritfarer are both cozy boat games about caring for animal friends. An honest comparison of what is alike and what differs.

By [Yos Riady](https://ashortsail.com/authors/yos-riady/) · Published 30 December 2026 · **Last checked: 20 November 2026**

**Both are cozy games about a boat, the sea and animal friends, but one is a story about goodbyes and the other is a daily round.** Spiritfarer (Thunder Lotus, 2020) is a hand-drawn 2D game where you care for spirits on a ferry. A Short Sail is a 3D sailing game where a tabby cat delivers mail, fishes and makes friends. Pick Spiritfarer for a moving story, and A Short Sail for a lighter life at sea.

Short answer first: **if you want a deep, emotional story and do not mind crying, play Spiritfarer. If you want a lighter game where you sail the boat yourself and come back for a round of errands, try A Short Sail.** We make A Short Sail, and Spiritfarer is one of the best cozy games there is, so we tried hard to be fair.

## Who makes each game

[Spiritfarer](https://store.steampowered.com/app/972660/) is by Thunder Lotus, a studio in Montreal. It came out in 2020 and is on PC, Mac, Linux, consoles and mobile. It is Verified for Steam Deck and takes about 25.5 hours, according to HowLongToBeat.

[A Short Sail](https://ashortsail.com/) is made by [Yos Riady](https://yos.io/), a solo developer. It is still in development and coming to Steam and itch.io in Q1 2027, for PC (Windows), Mac, the web and Steam Deck. The free demo plays in your browser now at [play.ashortsail.com](https://play.ashortsail.com/).

## What is alike

**A boat is your home.** In Spiritfarer, your ferry is where you live, work and keep your friends. In A Short Sail, your sailboat carries the post, it is where you fish from, and you customize it with new sails, hulls and more.

**Animal friends to care for.** Spiritfarer’s spirits take animal shapes: a deer, a frog, a snake, a hedgehog. You feed them and hug them. In A Short Sail, the islanders are animals too, such as a rabbit, a pelican and a beaver, and they become your friends, shown as hearts, when you help them.

**Islands to visit.** Both games send you from island to island, each with its own people and things to find.

**Fishing.** In Spiritfarer you fish off the back of the ferry. In A Short Sail you fish by day and by night, and different fish bite in different waters and at different hours.

**Storms as events.** Spiritfarer lets you sail into thunderstorms to catch lightning. A Short Sail has rain and storms that roll in over the sea.

**No rush.** Neither game has a fail state on land, and neither hurries you.

## What is different

**The heart of it.** Spiritfarer is about death. Each spirit is someone from Stella’s life, and when their story is done you take them to the Everdoor and say goodbye. It is tender and sad. A Short Sail is not about loss. The islands need your help, and your days are full of small, cheerful jobs.

**2D or 3D.** Spiritfarer is a hand-drawn 2D game, seen from the side, with some platforming. A Short Sail is a 3D game with bright low-poly islands and cel-shaded animal characters.

**Who sails the boat.** In Spiritfarer, you set a destination and the ferry goes there while you work on deck. In A Short Sail, sailing is the play: you catch the wind in your sail and steer.

**What you do all day.** Spiritfarer is a management game. You grow crops, cook, weave, smelt and build, to keep your passengers fed and happy. In A Short Sail, you pick up letters and parcels, pack them into your hold and deliver them to folks. There is no farm and no crafting chain.

**Your home.** In Spiritfarer the boat is the home, and you stack it with buildings. In A Short Sail you build your home island, one plank at a time, and give it a name of your own.

**A calendar.** A Short Sail has a weekly calendar of events: a fishing contest, a regatta, a lantern festival and a night market. Spiritfarer follows its story.

**Sea battles.** Spiritfarer has no combat at all. A Short Sail has gentle sea battles against storms and living waves, with no timers.

**Alone or together.** Spiritfarer has local co-op for two. A Short Sail plays alone or online with friends.

**Out now or coming soon.** Spiritfarer is out now. A Short Sail comes in Q1 2027, and only its demo is out now.

## Side by side

|  | Spiritfarer | A Short Sail |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Developer | Thunder Lotus | Yos Riady |
| Release | 2020 | Q1 2027 (in development) |
| You play | Stella, a ferrymaster for spirits | A tabby cat with a sailboat |
| Look | Hand-drawn 2D | Low-poly 3D, cel-shaded characters |
| Main thing you do | Build, farm, cook and care for spirits | Deliver mail between islands, fish and make friends |
| Sailing | The ferry sails itself | You catch the wind and steer |
| Tone | Warm and sad | Light and cheerful |
| Combat | None | Gentle sea battles only, no timers |
| Multiplayer | Local co-op for two | Alone or online with friends |
| Length | About 25.5 hours (HowLongToBeat) | Not shared yet |
| Platforms | PC, Mac, Linux, consoles, mobile | PC (Windows), Mac, Web, Steam Deck |

**Bottom line:** Spiritfarer is the better pick for a deep, emotional story that you finish. A Short Sail is the better pick if you want to steer the boat yourself, keep a lighter mood and sail online with friends.

## Who should play which

**Play Spiritfarer if** you want a story that matters, with characters you will miss. It is beautifully drawn and scored, and few games handle loss so gently. For more like it, see our [games like Spiritfarer](https://ashortsail.com/blog/games-like-spiritfarer/).

**Play A Short Sail if** you loved Spiritfarer’s boat, its sea and its animal friends, but want a lighter mood and a boat you steer yourself. It is also the pick if you want to sail with friends online. Try the [free demo](https://play.ashortsail.com/) first: it runs in your browser, and your save carries over to the full game.

**Play both if** you love boats. Spiritfarer is the one you finish and remember. A Short Sail is the one you come back to. Our [relaxing boat games](https://ashortsail.com/blog/relaxing-boat-games/) and [best cozy sailing games](https://ashortsail.com/blog/best-cozy-sailing-games/) have more.

## Our own game

We make [A Short Sail](https://ashortsail.com/), so this page is not neutral. Spiritfarer is a bigger and more finished game than ours, and we admire it. You can get it on [Steam](https://store.steampowered.com/app/972660/).

## Questions

### Is A Short Sail like Spiritfarer?

In spirit, yes: A Short Sail is like Spiritfarer in its boat, its islands and its animal friends. Both are gentle games where a boat takes you between islands and you look after animal characters. Spiritfarer is a 2D management game with a sad, warm story. A Short Sail is a 3D sailing game about the post, fishing and friends.

### Is A Short Sail as sad as Spiritfarer?

No, A Short Sail is not as sad as Spiritfarer. Spiritfarer is about death and saying goodbye, and most players cry at least once. A Short Sail is a lighter game. It has secrets to uncover, but its days are about errands, fishing and friends.

### Which game has more sailing?

A Short Sail has more sailing than Spiritfarer. You catch the wind and steer your sailboat yourself, in 3D. In Spiritfarer you pick a place on the map and the ferry sails there by itself, while you cook, garden and build on deck.

### Does either game have combat?

Spiritfarer has none. A Short Sail has no fighting on foot. At sea it has gentle battles against storms and living waves, never people or animals. They are single-player only, and there are no timers.

### Can I play them with a friend?

Spiritfarer has local co-op: a second player joins as Daffodil the cat. A Short Sail plays alone or online with friends: host a lobby or join one by its code or from a list of public lobbies, and ride along in a friend's boat.

### Are both on Steam Deck?

Spiritfarer is Verified for Steam Deck. A Short Sail comes to Steam in Q1 2027 for PC (Windows), Mac, the web and Steam Deck, and its free demo plays in your browser now at play.ashortsail.com.

-   [a short sail](https://ashortsail.com/blog/tags/a-short-sail/)
-   [boat games](https://ashortsail.com/blog/tags/boat-games/)
-   [island games](https://ashortsail.com/blog/tags/island-games/)
-   [cozy games](https://ashortsail.com/blog/tags/cozy-games/)

**Written by [Yos Riady](https://ashortsail.com/authors/yos-riady/)**

Yos Riady is the solo developer making A Short Sail, a cozy sailing game.

## Related guides

-   29 Dec 2026
    
    ### [Is A Short Sail like Zelda: The Wind Waker?](https://ashortsail.com/blog/is-a-short-sail-like-wind-waker/)
    
    A Short Sail and The Wind Waker share a small sailboat, a bright sea of islands and treasure maps. An honest look at what is alike and what is different.
    
    -   [a short sail](https://ashortsail.com/blog/tags/a-short-sail/)
    -   [sailing games](https://ashortsail.com/blog/tags/sailing-games/)
    -   [island games](https://ashortsail.com/blog/tags/island-games/)
    -   [cozy games](https://ashortsail.com/blog/tags/cozy-games/)
    
-   10 Dec 2026
    
    ### [A Short Sail vs Moonglow Bay: which to play?](https://ashortsail.com/blog/a-short-sail-vs-moonglow-bay/)
    
    A Short Sail and Moonglow Bay are both cozy boat games about fishing and helping a community. An honest comparison: what is alike and who should pick which.
    
    -   [a short sail](https://ashortsail.com/blog/tags/a-short-sail/)
    -   [fishing games](https://ashortsail.com/blog/tags/fishing-games/)
    -   [boat games](https://ashortsail.com/blog/tags/boat-games/)
    -   [cozy games](https://ashortsail.com/blog/tags/cozy-games/)
    
-   9 Dec 2026
    
    ### [A Short Sail vs Tchia: which to play?](https://ashortsail.com/blog/a-short-sail-vs-tchia/)
    
    A Short Sail and Tchia are both bright island games with boats and music. An honest comparison: what is alike, what is different and who should pick which.
    
    -   [a short sail](https://ashortsail.com/blog/tags/a-short-sail/)
    -   [sailing games](https://ashortsail.com/blog/tags/sailing-games/)
    -   [island games](https://ashortsail.com/blog/tags/island-games/)
    -   [cozy games](https://ashortsail.com/blog/tags/cozy-games/)
    

## A Short Sail

The cozy sailing game with a cat.

Coming soon to Steam and [itch.io](https://yosriady.itch.io/a-short-sail) [Play the free demo](https://play.ashortsail.com/)
